← Back to The Blog

Not Your Momma’s Approach to SEO

Published on October 20, 2022
Last updated on January 24th, 2024

Let’s start with everyone’s fave question:


Search Engine Optimization (SEO) is the method for indexing digital content across the web for the purpose of delivering perceived value to a user. Google, for example, "reads" the content on your website and assigns a numerical value which it uses in an ever-changing algorithm. That calculated value determines where you fall in search results.

Fun fact: You get 1,360,000,000 results if you search for “SEO” in Google. (Will this article increase it to 1,360,000,001?) 

What Getting Started with SEO Actually Looks Like as a Business Owner

Some of these search results for “SEO” will feature articles by MOZ, Neil Patel and Search Engine Land - all great resources for getting started. 10/10

From our experience, clients feel excited by the prospect of starting to implement SEO on their own websites. They’re researching keywords, writing new blog content weekly (ok, maybe monthly…) and maybe even adding ALT text to all of their images. WE LOVE TO SEE IT!

But, after a couple of months that excitement starts to fizzle because they’re not sure if what they’re doing is actually producing results. Where do they look? How can they tell? (We’re giving gold stars to anyone who’s logged into their Google Analytics account and at least tried to peruse the data!)

Something all of these beginner articles leave out is that Google uses over 200 different ranking “signals” for SEO. (We’re not lying! Here’s a complete list!) 

You, your mom, and every SEO agency can control some of the major ranking signal categories  to help improve performance, including:

  • Page-Level Factors
  • Site-Level Factors
  • Backlink Factors
  • User Interaction
  • Brand Signals
  • On-Site Webspam Factors

Then again, there are a few that are completely outside of your control:

  • Domain Factors - e.g. how long ago and where you registered your domain
  • Special Google Algorithm Rules - e.g. if the user has safe search turned on
  • Off-Site Webspam Factors - e.g. if you’re getting links from unrelated websites that you didn’t sign up for

Of course those articles don’t expect you to become an expert at all 200 overnight, but they leave out some key factors like how to measure website performance to see if the SEO that’s within your control is actually working.

“Not having a holistic approach to your SEO strategy prevents you from seeing results.”

—Erica Martin, Lord of Pixels

How to Develop a More Holistic Approach to SEO

1. Collect ALL the Data

We’ll tell you that there is no such thing as too much data. Collect everything. Collect it all! This will give you enough information to grow into. A few examples of data tracking include metrics and platforms include:

  • Google Analytics
  • Google Search Console
  • Google Ads/AdSense for digital advertising
  • YouTube/Vimeo for video playback information
  • The META Pixel for social media tracking
  • Email marketing platforms, like MailChimp or Convert Kit
  • Your CRM - whatever that may be

If you want to get really fancy, then you can utilize Google Tag Manager to collect more in-depth event information when it comes to any of the aforementioned tools. There are ways to find out what percentage of a video a particular user watches on your website, and whether or not the sound is on when they play it. 

2. Create a Digital Dashboard

Because there are sooooo many factors which play into Google’s search algorithm, and so many different data points, we recommend creating a high-level digital dashboard that pulls in as much data as possible to give you a comprehensive and holistic view of your digital presence.

Our personal favorite is to build out a monthly view of performance, starting with an overview of website performance across all channels, then drilling down into each individual channel (e.g. Organic, Referral, Direct and Paid).

From there we add in each individual social media channel we’re active on in order to look at metrics like our engagement rate and click-throughs to our website.

Finally, we incorporate our Google My Business profile.

3. Add Reference Points

Google updates its search algorithm frequently. (It’s annoying how often, really.) And, sometimes it’s difficult to know if the update is considered major or minor until after Google publishes a formal announcement a few weeks after-the-fact.

You can use tools like Semrush Sensor to look at SERP volatility. The higher the score is, the more likely an algorithm update was introduced by Google. The goal would be to monitor if there is a correlation between your website’s organic performance and changes in the algorithm. While the changes aren’t immediate, you may see a cause-and-effect relationship a month or two later. This can be a great indicator that based on the algorithm update, you now need to also update your approach to SEO.

Another great way to reference your data is based on the changes you make. For example, if you redesign your homepage, then it’s a good idea to add that benchmark to your reporting tools so you can compare performance before and after the refresh. The same can be applied to when you start/stop a new digital advertising campaign, or social media strategy.

4. Review Your Digital Reports

Congrats on adding ALL the data and even considering looking at that hot mess of numbers. 😂 We admit it: Attempting to review any type of digital report can feel overwhelming and difficult to make sense of. It takes time to learn how to interpret your data to get what you need out of it.

Here are a couple of questions you can start with: 

  • Which social media platforms are the most successful when it comes to customer acquisition? (This is not about general engagement, because it should not count when your mom likes your posts.)
  • Which digital platform are most of your leads generated through? Is it social media, email marketing, your website’s contact form, Calendly, or another networking resource?
  • What does your sales cycle look like, and does it include leads visiting and returning to your website to look up more information about your services?

If you don’t feel like you’re able to answer these questions based on your report, then try changing how the data is visualized to help you make sense of it. There’s no perfect way to build a chart!

5. Connect it Back to SEO

We’ve come full circle with why our strategy is not your momma’s approach to SEO. Some of the points we discussed in our concept of a holistic approach do not directly translate into an SEO strategy, but can help contribute to improving your website’s performance. And, the better your website performs overall, the more it will also show up in search results.

Other Noteworthy SEO-Related Things

We Don’t Focus on Off-Page SEO

We mentioned earlier that it’s difficult to manage every single ranking factor in Google’s algorithm, which is why we don’t necessarily focus on off-page SEO. Some things are outside of your control and not worth fretting over, when there are other factors you can focus on.

Backlinks are a hot topic when it comes to off-page SEO, which is a method of getting other websites to link back to your website. When done correctly and legitimately, backlinks are amazing, especially when the other website is a higher domain authority than your website. But, your backlink efforts will never outweigh your on-page SEO efforts, which is why we focus there first.

Pro-Tip: Privacy Policies are a Must-Have

It may seem far-fetched for a solopreneur to get into trouble, but privacy laws are now in place - and more coming in 2023 - to protect the personal information of residents of certain states with fines that can reach $2,500-$7,500 per website visitor. This can be as simple as tracking user behavior through Google Analytics - so be sure to have a privacy policy on your website!

© 2018–2024. All this good stuff is ours. Website design and development by... us!🤪

P.S. Here's a link to our privacy policy that literally no one asked for.

linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram